In the realm of North America, the film is known as “The Watchers”, while in the UK and Ireland it is referred to as “The Watched”. However, despite this difference in titles, the overall plot of Ishana Night Shyamalan’s debut feature remains convoluted and disjointed. The storyline revolves around a simple premise of a single-location genre set in a cabin in the woods, but somehow manages to become needlessly complex and ultimately uninteresting.
A Misguided Thriller
From the outset, the film sets the stage with a voiceover detailing a mysterious forest that lures in lost souls and never lets them escape. This introduction leads to a series of horror tropes and conventional scares that fail to deliver any real sense of terror or intrigue. The narrative then shifts to Galway, where we meet Mina, a pet-shop worker grappling with existential turmoil and still mourning the loss of her mother. As she embarks on a journey to deliver a parrot to a zoo, strange occurrences begin to unfold, setting the stage for a spiraling series of events.
Mina stumbles upon an isolated cabin known as “The Coop”, where she encounters a group of residents who have been trapped there for an extended period. The mysterious nature of the cabin, along with its inhabitants and the looming presence of unknown creatures on the other side of a two-way mirror, adds layers of intrigue to the plot. However, as the story progresses, the film veers into a convoluted exploration of changelings, ancient societies of the fae, and a shadowy figure known as “The Professor”.
Despite moments of effective horror and tension, the film struggles to maintain a coherent narrative as it delves into excessive exposition and unnecessary backstory. The heavy-handed allegory surrounding Mina’s character and the sporadic adherence to established rules within the film’s universe detract from the overall viewing experience. As the storyline approaches what could be a natural conclusion, it instead extends into a prolonged and disjointed final act that overstays its welcome.
The final act of the film, filled with twists and turns, fails to provide a satisfying conclusion to the narrative. The ambiguity surrounding the creatures, the cabin, and the characters’ fates leaves the audience with more questions than answers. Despite occasional moments of suspense and visual flair, “The Watchers” (or “The Watched”) ultimately falls short of delivering a cohesive and engaging horror experience.
Ishana Night Shyamalan’s debut feature struggles to balance its ambitious premise with cohesive storytelling and compelling character development. While the film offers glimpses of atmospheric horror and intriguing concept, it ultimately falters under the weight of its convoluted plot and lackluster execution. “The Watchers” (or “The Watched”) serves as a cautionary tale of the pitfalls of overcomplicating a genre film and losing sight of the core elements that make a horror movie truly memorable.
Leave a Reply